# New Relic vs PagerDuty: Do You Need Both?

Source: https://www.observeone.com/compare/new-relic-vs-pagerduty

[ObserveOne](/)[Features](/#features)[Pricing](/#pricing)[Blog](/blog)[CLI](/cli)[Docs](/docs)

[Sign in](https://app.observeone.com/auth?tab=signin)[Start Free](https://app.observeone.com/auth?tab=signup)

- [Compare](/compare)
- New Relic vs PagerDuty

# New Relic vs PagerDuty

New Relic is an observability platform for every engineer. PagerDuty is digital operations management and incident response. Here is where they differ on features, pricing and fit.

ObserveOne TeamData reviewed July 2026

- [Verdict](#verdict)
- [Feature comparison](#features)
- [Pros and cons](#pros-cons)
- [FAQ](#faq)

New Relic and PagerDuty are often evaluated together by teams building out their reliability stack. New Relic (observability platform for every engineer, founded 2008) is typically a fit for Developers, DevOps Teams, and SREs, while PagerDuty (digital operations management and incident response, founded 2009) leans toward DevOps Teams, SREs, and On-call Engineers. Both cover 8 of the same core capabilities, so the decision usually comes down to where they diverge.

## New Relic vs PagerDuty: Our Verdict

On capability breadth, New Relic pulls ahead here: it uniquely offers Synthetic Monitoring, Real User Monitoring, API & Browser Testing, and Uptime Monitoring, among others. Choose New Relic if those matter to your workflow; PagerDuty (Free (5 users), Pro $21/user/mo, Business $41/user/mo (+ Add-ons)) remains a solid option if Status Page is what you need.

## New Relic

Observability platform for every engineer

Pricing: 100 GB/mo free data ingest, $0.40/GB beyond. Standard from $10/mo/user, Pro from $349/user/mo

Founded: 2008

Best for: Developers, DevOps Teams, SREs

[Visit New Relic →](https://newrelic.com)

## PagerDuty

Digital operations management and incident response

Pricing: Free (5 users), Pro $21/user/mo, Business $41/user/mo (+ Add-ons)

Founded: 2009

Best for: DevOps Teams, SREs, On-call Engineers

[Visit PagerDuty →](https://pagerduty.com)

## Feature Comparison

7 of 18 capabilities separate these two. Those come first.

FeatureNew RelicPagerDuty

Where they differ (7)

Synthetic MonitoringNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: no

Real User MonitoringNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: no

API & Browser TestingNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: no

Uptime MonitoringNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: no

Multi-Location ChecksNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: no

SSL MonitoringNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: no

Status PageNew Relic: noPagerDuty: yes

Both tools have (8)

AI-PoweredNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

AlertingNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

Slack IntegrationNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

CI/CD IntegrationNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

Free TierNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

API AccessNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

DashboardsNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

Incident ManagementNew Relic: yesPagerDuty: yes

Neither tool has (3)

Self-Healing TestsNew Relic: noPagerDuty: no

Open SourceNew Relic: noPagerDuty: no

On-Premise / Self-HostNew Relic: noPagerDuty: no

### Only in New Relic

- Synthetic Monitoring
- Real User Monitoring
- API & Browser Testing
- Uptime Monitoring
- Multi-Location Checks
- SSL Monitoring

### Only in PagerDuty

- Status Page

### New Relic

Pros

- + Generous free tier (100GB/month)
- + Unified full-stack observability
- + Strong synthetic monitoring capabilities
- + Usage-based pricing is more predictable

Cons

- − UI can feel complex and overwhelming
- − No self-healing test automation
- − Costs spike with high data volume
- − Alert fatigue issues reported by users

### PagerDuty

Pros

- + Industry-leading incident response workflows
- + Reliable on-call scheduling and escalation
- + Wide integration ecosystem
- + Strong automation with runbooks

Cons

- − Expensive for small teams
- − Complex to configure initially
- − No monitoring, needs to pair with a dedicated monitoring tool
- − Alert fatigue without tuning

## Frequently Asked Questions

### What is the main difference between New Relic and PagerDuty?

New Relic spots the problem. PagerDuty pages whoever is on call, and New Relic can send it alerts natively. See where they overlap and what each costs.

### How do New Relic and PagerDuty compare on pricing?

New Relic pricing: 100 GB/mo free data ingest, $0.40/GB beyond. Standard from $10/mo/user, Pro from $349/user/mo. PagerDuty pricing: Free (5 users), Pro $21/user/mo, Business $41/user/mo (+ Add-ons). Evaluate against your check volume and team size; entry pricing rarely reflects total cost at scale.

### Which is better for Developers?

New Relic is designed with Developers, DevOps Teams, and SREs in mind, whereas PagerDuty targets DevOps Teams, SREs, and On-call Engineers. If your team matches the former profile, New Relic is usually the closer fit.

### Can ObserveOne replace New Relic and PagerDuty?

No. It does a different job. On-call and status tools decide who gets paged and what customers see, but they need a detection layer feeding them. ObserveOne is that layer: scheduled synthetic checks on your critical journeys that catch the outage and hand it to your incident process.

## What ObserveOne adds next to New Relic and PagerDuty

On-call and status tools decide who gets paged and what customers see, but they need a detection layer feeding them. ObserveOne is that layer: scheduled synthetic checks on your critical journeys that catch the outage and hand it to your incident process. The free tier covers enough to try it on one critical journey.

[Check your site free, no signup](/community/tools/website-status-checker)[Compare More Tools](/compare)

## Related Comparisons

[ObserveOne vs New Relic](/compare/observeone-vs-new-relic)[ObserveOne vs PagerDuty](/compare/observeone-vs-pagerduty)[New Relic vs Pingdom](/compare/new-relic-vs-pingdom)[New Relic vs Grafana](/compare/new-relic-vs-grafana)

## Alternatives to each tool

Each tool has its own alternatives page too, not just this matchup.

[New Relic alternativesWhat people move to when they leave New Relic.](/alternatives/new-relic)[PagerDuty alternativesWhat people move to when they leave PagerDuty.](/alternatives/pagerduty)

## Features Both Tools Share

AI-PoweredAlertingSlack IntegrationCI/CD IntegrationFree TierAPI AccessDashboardsIncident Management

## How we compare

- Feature flags and pricing come from each vendor&#x27;s public docs and pricing pages, last reviewed June 2026. Spot an error? [Tell us](/contact) and we&#x27;ll fix the data.
- ObserveOne is our product. The data is collected the same way for every tool; the recommendations are ours.

ObserveOne

Agentic QA and synthetic monitoring built for engineering teams. Plan, generate, and run suites from the web UI. Connect to CI for reliable coverage across critical journeys.

### Product

- [Features](/#features)
- [Pricing](/#pricing)
- [QA Coverage](/qa-coverage)
- [API Monitoring](/api-monitoring)
- [Free Website Check](/free-website-check)

### Developers

- [CLI](/cli)
- [Docs](/docs)
- [For Agents](/agents)
- [Self-host (oo-workers)](/workers)
- [Status Pages](/status)
- [Netlify Extension](https://app.netlify.com/extensions/mzs1lgc3-observeone)

### Resources

- [Blog](/blog)
- [Bug Book](/bug-book)
- [Guides](/community/guides)
- [Tools](/community/tools)
- [Error Dictionary](/community/errors)

### Compare

- [Tool Comparisons](/compare)
- [Tool Alternatives](/alternatives)
- [Best by Category](/best)
- [Search](/search)

© 2026 ObserveOne. All rights reserved.

[About](/about)[Privacy Policy](/privacy)[Terms of Service](/terms)[Affiliates](/affiliates)[Become an Affiliate](/affiliate-terms)
